Rent or buying, – an economists view point

Sue Tierney

I was fascinated to read the article in NZ herald on line today  – Rent don’t buy, says economist – Shamubeel Eaqub, by Anne Gibson

His argument seems to be based on the belief that a home is a business. An interesting view point. In all of my years in lending and finance I have never had a client come and tell me that the want to borrow money to buy a business – a residential home that they were going to live in. Many will ask to borrow money to buy a rental property, and I would totally agree with Mr Eaqub, that is a business. But this is not basis of the article. He refers to your own home as a business.

I also couldn’t understand why Aucklander’s were singled out as having a love affair with property in the article.  During my time as President and on the board of the Auckland Property Investors Association I was fortunate to meet many amazing, astute property investors from all walks of life,  living in all parts of our country. This love affair with property is not an Auckland issue.

So why do we want our own home? We all have our own reasons but for most of us:

Its part of growing up and becoming an adult. To plant our gardens. Invite our friends over for a BBQ, bring up a family, have pets, do the things we like doing at home. Ultimately, we all want some level of certainty. To be able to come home at night to a place we call our own. Owning our own home does that for us.

Only last week I was driving through the North Island for a couple of days skiing at Turoa. I was saddened to see the state of many properties, run down, badly in need of a good paint job. Again this is not a provincial issue, and I am sure there are many homes like it in our major cities. So again Mr Eaqub I disagree, not everybody spends a fortune maintaining their homes.

The article uses buying shares compared to buying a home (business). Well I have very clear memories of buying shares in 1987 when the market was going crazy. Hard earned cash invested in the share market. I haven’t seen a cent of that money since. It was a hard lesson but one I needed to learn. In 1996 I was fortunate enough to buy a block of flats in Christchurch. The total purchase price was borrowed using the security of my own home. I still own the flats today and yes as we all expect they have increased in value significantly.

I don’t have an issue with anybody buying shares. That’s an investment strategy in itself, but I cannot see how us ordinary New Zealander’s would even consider renting for life and investing in a share market that we don’t understand and don’t have any control over.

I’m going to stick to my current strategy of owning my own little apartment and buying rental properties. It works for me.

We're here to help you with home loans, personal finance & insurance.

Latest Insights

by Sue Tierney 7 May 2025
Here’s a tip that might come in handy: Get your phone out, open the camera, and video any possession that you might need to claim on your insurance one day. We sincerely hope you never suffer a burglary, fire or flood – but if you do, you’ll be glad you made a record. A few years ago, we made this suggestion to one of our clients. He videoed his stuff – and wouldn’t you know, he was burgled just two days later. This leads to another piece of advice: Make sure you mention this to your insurer, just in case you find yourself in the same position as the person above. You wouldn’t want the insurance company to start wondering if you’d set the whole thing up. Stranger things have happened. A reminder that we don't offer fire and general insurance. We have no skin in this particular game – we simply want to be helpful. However, if you’d like to talk about these types of insurance policies, we can refer you to some trusted advisers. Note that we don’t get paid referral fees or commissions if you arrange insurance with these people: Our contact at Glenn Stone Insurance (GSI) is Lynley Evans, who manages some of our own insurance. Contact her at lynley@gsi.nz You can also use the tool on Frank Risk online. Click on the link here . Alternatively, we’d be happy to refer you to Tower Insurance. We’d need your authorisation to send them your contact details. Note that Tower do pay us a referral fee. Talk to us if you need to look at your life and health cover. If you haven’t reviewed your life, health, trauma, or income protection insurance recently, now may be a good time to do so. This is especially important if your life has changed. Did you get married, start a family, retire, come out of a relationship, take out a mortgage, or experience any other major changes in recent years? We’re not trying to sell you anything – just helping ensure your cover still meets your needs.  Click on the link below to set up a call. There’s no charge.
by Sue Tierney 7 May 2025
The reason is simple. Something you may not think is important could actually matter a lot. It could save (or cost) you thousands of dollars. That’s why we’re always keen to catch up. Talking face-to-face on a video call is an opportunity to find out the things that don’t appear in an email or bank statement. Here’s an example: When a 'cash contribution' from the bank is a bad idea. Banks often use cashback offers or other sweeteners to encourage you to sign on the dotted line. This can be a good deal…or it can be a terrible one. It all depends on your personal circumstances. When we talk to you, we’ll ask questions like these: “Could you reduce your loan in the next few years with a lump sum from KiwiSaver?” “Are you expecting a windfall, such as an inheritance or company shares?” “Are you thinking of selling your house and buying in a cheaper location within the next three years?” Your answers to these questions (and the other questions we ask) will determine the type of loan that’s right for you. The sugar hit of a cash contribution from the bank might turn out to be a false economy, because it could end up locking you into a loan term that doesn’t match your objectives. Here's another example. Refinancing your loan might not be a done deal. Refixing with your bank is usually pretty straightforward. But moving to a new bank – i.e. refinancing your mortgage – may not be. First of all, you will have to go through a complete re-application process. Every lender will need a lot of detail, and their questions could be intrusive. That’s fair enough – they are checking if they want you as a customer. It’s a bigger deal than simply rolling over an existing loan. And you may not even be approved. Then you’re back to square one. Of course, there are times when refinancing is the right option – and we’ll be very happy to do it for you. But first we need to dig into your particular circumstances. So we ask a lot of questions. We're here to help you find the right loan. Your emails and phone calls are always welcome. At Sue Tierney Mortgages, we’re here to give advice whenever you’re thinking about rolling over a loan, taking out finance or changing your insurance. Try us. Click on the link below to set up a call. There’s no charge.
by Sue Tierney 25 March 2025
As Registered Financial Advisers , we’re all about doing the right thing for our clients. A big part of that is making sure you don’t pay a dollar more than absolutely necessary.

Wealth creation is not what you own. It’s what you control.

Deliver Sue’s insights straight to your inbox.